Friday 26 April 2024

Assignment- 5 Research Project Writing: Dissertation Writing - Research Writing

Name: Ghanshyam Katariya

Paper 210A: Research Project Writing: Dissertation Writing - Research Writing 

Subject Code: 22417

Topic Name:  Navigating Narratives: A Narratological Exploration Of Nonlinear Storytelling In Films

Batch: M.A. Sem-4(2022-24)

Roll No: 7

Enrolment No: 4069206420220017

Email Address: gkatariya67@gmail.com

Submitted to: Smt. S. B. Gardi, Department of English, MKBU


Chapter 5:

Conclusion:

The analyses of the first two films, Memento and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind highlight the profound impact of nonlinear narrative structures on our understanding of memory, identity, and the construction of subjective realities. Both films employ unconventional techniques, such as reverse chronology, fragmented memories, and the interweaving of past and present, challenging the traditional notions of storytelling.


Memento, through its dual narrative structure alternating between chronological and reverse chronological sequences, immerses the audience in Leonard's disorienting experience of anterograde amnesia. The film's fragmented narrative mirrors the unreliability and discontinuity of Leonard's memory, forcing viewers to grapple with the subjective nature of truth and the malleability of personal narratives. The revelation that the Sammy Jankis story is a fictionalized version of Leonard's own case further underscores the fallibility of memory and the construction of self-mythologies.


Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, on the other hand, utilizes a reverse chronological structure that unravels Joel and Clementine's relationship in reverse, evoking the emotional resonance of memories and their impact on personal identity. The film's nonlinear structure, coupled with the distortion of Joel's memories, blurs the boundaries between reality and fantasy, inviting audiences to contemplate the profound implications of erasing memories and the inextricable link between lived experiences and the self.


These two seminal works demonstrate the power of nonlinear storytelling in exploring the complexities of memory, identity, and the subjective nature of truth. Through their innovative narrative structures and thematic explorations, Memento and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind have redefined the boundaries of cinematic storytelling, leaving a lasting impact on our understanding of the human condition.


Quentin Tarantino's Pulp Fiction and Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon are groundbreaking films that radically redefined cinematic storytelling through their innovative use of nonlinear, fragmented narrative structures presenting multiple subjective perspectives. Pulp Fiction interweaves three separate crime storylines in a pulp fiction pastiche, jumping between different plot threads across intersecting timelines. This postmodern, hyperlink approach mirrors the chaotic experiences of the film's morally ambiguous underworld characters, inviting audiences to actively reassemble the interconnected storylines. Rashomon recounts a pivotal rape and murder through four starkly contradictory testimonies, each shaped by the narrator's individual biases and subjective experiences. By denying any objective account, Kurosawa compels viewers to confront profound questions about truth, human perception, and the fallibility of memory.


While Pulp Fiction adopts a stylized, ironic nostalgia for past genres, Rashomon embraces stark philosophical realism by stripping away factual certainty. Yet both deconstruct classical linear conventions by centralizing the inherent subjectivity and malleability of human perspectives. Their nonlinear structures expand cinema's capacity for philosophical inquiry and self-reflexive audience engagement. Pulp Fiction's intersecting crime arcs elucidate moral ambiguities and the struggle for meaning amidst violence. Rashomon's contradictory testimonies illustrate the broader "Rashomon effect" through metaphor, impacting justice, interpersonal dynamics, and belief systems predicated on inevitably biased recollections.  


By revolutionizing cinematic language through audacious multi-perspectival structures, these masterpieces transcended from cult sensations to mainstream critical and commercial success. They connected with audiences by immersing them in intricate, subjective experiences mirroring reality's fragmentation. Tarantino and Kurosawa's unique cultural voices channeled through nonlinear innovations cemented their influential legacies. Pulp Fiction and Rashomon ultimately ruptured classical traditions by embracing relativism over objectivity, upending linear storytelling assumptions while welcoming nuanced worldviews. Their nonlinear experiments crystallized cinema's expanded artistic frontiers for probing philosophical complexities through radical, multi-perspectival narratives.


The nonlinear storytelling techniques employed in films such as "Memento," "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," "Pulp Fiction," and "Rashomon" transcend conventional narrative structures, offering audiences immersive experiences that challenge perceptions of time, memory, and reality. These films experiment with narrative fragmentation, reverse chronology, and multiple subjective perspectives to delve into the complexities of human experiences and the construction of subjective truths. While each film explores distinct themes and narratives, they collectively showcase the transformative power of nonlinear storytelling in reshaping cinematic language and inviting audiences to explore the intricate interplay between memory, identity, and perception.


Reverse chronology is a prominent technique utilized in films like "Memento" and "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind." Instead of following a chronological progression, these films present events in reverse order, starting from the end and moving backwards towards the beginning. In "Memento," the color sequences unfold in reverse chronological order, while the black-and-white sequences progress chronologically. "Eternal Sunshine" employs a reverse chronological structure, starting with the aftermath of Joel and Clementine's relationship and gradually revealing their past memories in reverse order.


Fragmented memories and non-chronological sequences are also widely used to disrupt the linear flow of the narrative. In "Memento," Leonard's condition of anterograde amnesia leads to a fragmented portrayal of events, with the audience piecing together his experiences from disjointed fragments. "Eternal Sunshine" visually depicts the disintegration and blurring of Joel's memories, with scenes seamlessly blending and transitioning in a dreamlike manner, reflecting the malleable nature of human recollection.


Multiple conflicting perspectives are another technique employed to challenge the notion of objective truth. In "Rashomon," the same event is recounted from the disparate viewpoints of four individuals, each account presenting a different version of the truth. This nonlinear structure forces the audience to confront the subjectivity of perception and the unreliability of personal testimony.


‘Pulp Fiction’ employs a non-chronological, intersecting storyline approach, with different character stories presented in fragmented sequences. The film's audacious departure from conventional storytelling techniques defies linear chronology and challenges the audience's expectations, inviting them to piece together the interconnected narratives through careful observation and analysis.


These nonlinear storytelling techniques not only disrupt the traditional narrative flow but also serve as powerful tools for exploring complex themes, character development, and audience engagement. By challenging the audience's expectations and forcing them to actively participate in the construction of meaning, these films invite deeper contemplation on the nature of memory, perception, and the subjective nature of truth.


By employing nonlinear narrative structures, filmmakers can intricately weave together thematic threads that resonate with audiences on a deeper level. Through the unconventional presentation of events and perspectives, these films create opportunities to delve into the subjective nature of truth, the fallibility of memory, and the complexities of moral ambiguity. This allows viewers to engage with these themes in a more nuanced and introspective manner, as they are prompted to question their own understanding of reality and morality. The nonlinear storytelling techniques serve as a catalyst for exploring these multifaceted themes, enriching the cinematic experience and leaving a lasting impact on the audience's perception of the human condition.


Nonlinear narratives effectively convey complex themes and ideas by subverting traditional storytelling conventions and challenging the audience's perceptions and assumptions. These techniques allow filmmakers to explore profound concepts such as the subjective nature of truth, the unreliability of memory, and moral ambiguity in thought-provoking and immersive ways.


One of the central themes conveyed through nonlinear narratives is the subjective nature of truth. Films like "Rashomon" and "Memento" undermine the notion of objective reality by presenting multiple conflicting perspectives and accounts of the same event. In "Rashomon," the contradictory narratives of the four individuals involved in the incident highlight the inherent biases and self-interests that shape personal testimony, casting doubt on the existence of a single, authoritative truth. Similarly, "Memento" challenges the reliability of memory and perception, as Leonard's condition of anterograde amnesia forces the audience to question the veracity of his recollections and the narratives he constructs.


By manipulating chronology and duration, these films create distinct fictional universes where the rules of realism are disregarded, transporting the audience to a different state of consciousness. The nonlinear structure mirrors the subjective experience of perception and memory, inviting the viewer to confront their own biases and assumptions about the nature of truth.


Closely tied to the theme of subjective truth is the exploration of the unreliability of memory. Films like "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" and "Memento" utilize fragmented memories, reverse chronology, and non-chronological sequences to convey the malleable and ephemeral nature of human recollection. In "Eternal Sunshine," the visual disintegration of Joel's memories and the dreamlike transitions between scenes reflect the fragility and impermanence of memory. "Memento," on the other hand, immerses the audience in Leonard's disorienting experience of anterograde amnesia, forcing them to grapple with the limitations and distortions of memory.


Through these nonlinear techniques, filmmakers challenge the traditional representation of time and space in cinema. As Eenoo suggests, "the sense of time in a movie is closely dependent on the story development,"(Eenoo) and by manipulating chronology, these films create a distinct fictional universe where the audience's understanding of psychological processes and experiences is reshaped.


Nonlinear narratives effectively explore themes of moral ambiguity and the complexities of human behavior. "Pulp Fiction," with its non-chronological, intersecting storylines, presents morally ambiguous characters who defy easy categorization as heroes or villains. The film's shifting perspectives and fragmented narratives force the audience to confront the contradictions and ambiguities inherent in the characters' actions and motivations, challenging conventional notions of right and wrong.


Similarly, "Memento" and "Eternal Sunshine" delve into the ethical dilemmas surrounding the manipulation of memory and personal identity. The films raise profound questions about the consequences of erasing painful memories and the indelible impact they have on our sense of self, inviting the audience to grapple with the moral implications of tampering with the fundamental building blocks of human experience.


By subverting traditional narrative structures and temporal linearity, these films create immersive experiences that resonate with the audience on a deeper level. As Eenoo notes, "the experience finds meaning in cinematic time and space, two abstract representations of real time and space."(Eenoo) The nonlinear approach allows filmmakers to transcend the boundaries of realism and transport the audience into a state of contemplation and self-reflection, where they are forced to confront the complexities of human existence, the fragility of memory, and the elusive nature of truth.


Nonlinear narratives contribute to character development and thematic depth by presenting different facets of a character's personality and actions across various narrative threads. The fragmented portrayal of characters in films like "Pulp Fiction" and "Memento" creates multidimensional and nuanced depictions, inviting the audience to piece together a complex understanding of motivations and behaviors.


Nonlinear storytelling techniques are not mere gimmicks or stylistic flourishes; they are deliberate artistic choices that serve to enhance dramatic tension, facilitate thematic exploration, and challenge the audience's perceptions and assumptions. By manipulating chronology, duration, and perspective, these films create distinct fictional universes that transcend the boundaries of realism, inviting the audience to engage with profound themes and ideas in a way that linear narratives often cannot.


As Eenoo aptly states, "time is a primordial element of manipulation in narrative,"(Eenoo) and it is through the subversion of traditional temporal structures that these nonlinear films effectively convey the subjective nature of truth, the unreliability of memory, moral ambiguity, and the complexities of human experience.


Nonlinear storytelling techniques have profound implications for character development, audience engagement, emotional resonance, and thematic depth. By departing from traditional linear narratives, these films create immersive and thought-provoking experiences that challenge the audience's perceptions and assumptions.


One of the most significant implications of nonlinear storytelling is its impact on character development. As Suganya and Padmanabhan suggest, "the nonlinear narrative is not concerned about chain of events rather it emphasizes to scrutinize the action, thought, living experience and feeling of the characters in the story." (Suganya and Padmanabhan) This approach allows filmmakers to present different facets of a character's personality and motivations across various narrative threads, creating multidimensional and nuanced depictions. In "Memento," for example, the fragmented portrayal of Leonard's experiences and interactions with other characters invites the audience to piece together a complex understanding of his psyche and the driving forces behind his actions (Buckland).


Nonlinear narratives foster active audience engagement by subverting expectations and challenging traditional storytelling conventions. By presenting events out of chronological order or through multiple conflicting perspectives, these films demand a heightened level of cognitive involvement from the viewers, prompting them to actively participate in the construction of meaning (Hven). As Suganya and Padmanabhan  note, "Cognitive psychologists believe that the human existence in the world is determined by his performance, behaviour, cogitation, premonition and expressing social emotions like sympathy and empathy."(Suganya and Padmanabhan) Nonlinear storytelling techniques tap into these cognitive processes, inviting the audience to empathize with characters, contemplate their actions, and engage in a deeper level of emotional and intellectual investment.


The nonlinear structure has significant implications for emotional resonance and thematic depth. By disrupting the traditional linear flow of events, these films create a sense of disorientation and uncertainty that mirrors the complexities of human experience. In "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," for instance, the reverse chronology and visual representation of Joel's disintegrating memories evoke a profound sense of loss and poignancy, enhancing the emotional resonance of the film's exploration of memory, identity, and the consequences of forgetting (Lapointe).


"The nonlinear narrative structure is determined by dissimilarity of time and events on the account of story. The Universe has linear functional system which is conflated by past, present and future."(Suganya and Padmanabhan) By subverting this linear temporal structure, nonlinear narratives create distinct fictional universes that transcend the boundaries of realism, allowing for a deeper exploration of complex themes and ideas. "Rashomon," for example, effectively conveys the subjective nature of truth and the unreliability of memory through its presentation of multiple conflicting perspectives (Redfern).


The fragmented and non-chronological narrative structure of films like "Pulp Fiction" contributes to the exploration of moral ambiguity and the complexities of human behavior. The intersecting storylines and shifting perspectives force the audience to confront the contradictions and ambiguities inherent in the characters' actions and motivations, challenging conventional notions of right and wrong (Wang).


Nonlinear storytelling techniques also have implications for emotional resonance. By presenting events out of sequence or through fragmented memories, these films create a sense of disorientation and uncertainty that mirrors the complexities of human experience. In "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," for instance, the reverse chronology and visual representation of Joel's disintegrating memories evoke a profound sense of loss and poignancy, enhancing the emotional resonance of the film's exploration of memory, identity, and the consequences of forgetting (Lapointe).


Nonlinear storytelling techniques are powerful tools for exploring the complexities of human experience, challenging audience perceptions, and fostering a deeper level of emotional and intellectual engagement. By subverting traditional narrative structures and temporal linearity, these films create immersive and thought-provoking experiences that transcend the boundaries of realism and invite the audience to confront profound themes and ideas in a way that linear narratives often cannot.


This study provides a comprehensive analysis of nonlinear storytelling techniques employed across several seminal films, including Memento, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Pulp Fiction, and Rashomon. By examining these films through a narratological lens, the study offers insights into how nonlinear structures shape narrative construction, character development, thematic exploration, and audience engagement.


One of the key contributions is the exploration of how nonlinear narratives challenge traditional narratological concepts and theories. The study supports the idea proposed by scholars like Hven (year) that these films force viewers to reconsider the cognitive and representational dominance within narratology by actively involving the audience in the process of piecing together the fragmented narrative. The findings demonstrate how nonlinear techniques subvert the conventional notions of temporal linearity, causality, and narrative progression, inviting a reevaluation of the fundamental principles that govern traditional storytelling.


The study extends existing narratological theories by examining the implications of nonlinear storytelling on thematic depth and character development. The analysis of films like Pulp Fiction and Rashomon supports Wang's (year) assertion that the non-chronological, intersecting storylines and multiple conflicting perspectives contribute to the exploration of complex themes such as moral ambiguity, the subjective nature of truth, and the complexities of human behavior. Additionally, the findings corroborate Buckland's (year) observation that the fragmented portrayal of characters across various narrative threads creates multidimensional and nuanced depictions, facilitating a deeper understanding of their motivations and actions.


The study also challenges certain narratological assumptions by highlighting the emotional resonance achieved through nonlinear techniques. Contrary to the notion that nonlinear structures may hinder emotional engagement, the analysis of films like Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and Memento demonstrates how these techniques can effectively convey profound themes and evoke powerful emotional responses. The findings support Lapointe's (year) assertion that the reverse chronology and visual representation of disintegrating memories in Eternal Sunshine enhance the poignancy and emotional resonance of the film's exploration of memory, identity, and the consequences of forgetting.


The study contributes to the understanding of nonlinear narratives as a means of challenging audience perceptions and fostering active engagement. The analysis aligns with the observations of scholars like Redfern (year) and Davis et al. (year), who highlight how films like Rashomon and Memento force viewers to confront their own biases, assumptions, and interpretations by presenting multiple conflicting perspectives and withholding definitive evidence.


By synthesizing the theoretical contributions of various scholars and analyzing the narratological implications of nonlinear storytelling across multiple films, this study offers a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of these unconventional narrative techniques. It highlights the ways in which nonlinear narratives challenge traditional narratological concepts, extend existing theories, and contribute to a deeper exploration of complex themes, character development, and audience engagement.


The study on nonlinear storytelling techniques in films identified several limitations that may affect the depth and breadth of its findings. Firstly, while the analysis included seminal films like Memento, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Pulp Fiction, and Rashomon, the sample size remained relatively small. A more extensive selection covering a wider array of films across various genres and time periods could offer a more comprehensive understanding of nonlinear storytelling and its implications on narrative structure.


The study primarily relied on qualitative analytical methods, such as literature review and critical analysis of films. While these approaches are valuable, incorporating quantitative methods like audience surveys or empirical data on viewer engagement could provide additional insights. Quantitative analysis could offer a more nuanced understanding of how audiences perceive and engage with nonlinear narratives, complementing the qualitative findings.


The study mainly focused on nonlinear narratives within Western cinema, particularly American and European films. This limited scope may overlook the rich traditions of nonlinear storytelling in other cultural contexts. Including films from diverse cultural backgrounds could uncover unique narratological approaches and broaden the understanding of nonlinear storytelling's impact across different societies and historical periods.



Moving forward, future research in the realm of nonlinear storytelling presents several promising avenues for exploration. Firstly, there is a need to investigate emerging nonlinear techniques that may evolve as filmmaking progresses. This entails identifying and scrutinizing new approaches to nonlinear storytelling, assessing how they affect narrative structure, and gauging their effectiveness in conveying complex themes and captivating audiences.


Comparative studies across different cultural contexts could offer valuable insights into the diverse traditions of nonlinear narrative. Such research could shed light on how cultural influences shape storytelling practices and audience reception of nonlinear narratives.


Delving deeper into audience reception and cognitive processing of nonlinear narratives could provide a better understanding of how viewers perceive and engage with these unconventional storytelling techniques. Collaborations with cognitive scientists and psychologists could facilitate a nuanced exploration of the psychological and neurological mechanisms involved.


The exploration of nonlinear storytelling extends beyond traditional cinema into realms such as transmedia and interactive narratives. Investigating how nonlinear techniques manifest and function in these emerging formats could unveil new dimensions of audience engagement and immersive storytelling experiences.


Future research could focus on thematic explorations within nonlinear narratives, delving into specific topics such as psychological states, trauma, or existential themes. This targeted approach could yield deeper insights into how nonlinear techniques contribute to the portrayal and exploration of complex thematic elements.


By acknowledging the current study's limitations and proposing these avenues for future research, the field can continue to advance its understanding of nonlinear storytelling techniques, their narratological implications, and their impact on audience engagement and thematic exploration. Embracing multidisciplinary perspectives will be key to enriching the field of narratology and its application to unconventional narrative forms.


This study has provided a thorough exploration of nonlinear storytelling techniques in cinema, examining how films like Memento, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Pulp Fiction, and Rashomon defy traditional narrative structures to convey complex themes and engage audiences in profound ways. Through the analysis of these seminal works, we have uncovered the transformative impact of nonlinear narratives on narrative construction, character development, and audience engagement.


While this study has shed light on the narratological implications of nonlinear storytelling, it is important to recognize its limitations and the need for further research. By continuing to explore emerging techniques, cross-cultural variations, and audience reception, we can deepen our understanding of nonlinear narratives and their role in shaping cinematic experiences.


Nonlinear storytelling represents a dynamic and evolving aspect of cinematic storytelling, offering filmmakers a rich tapestry of narrative possibilities to explore the intricacies of memory, identity, and subjective truth. As we look to the future of cinema, nonlinear narratives will undoubtedly continue to captivate audiences and challenge our perceptions of storytelling conventions.


Works Cited

Buckland, Warren, editor. Puzzle Films: Complex Storytelling in Contemporary Cinema. Wiley, 2009.

Eenoo, Cedric van. “Storytelling: Time, Space, Intervals.” opus.lib.uts.edu.au, OPUS Open Publications of UTS Scholars, 2018, https://opus.lib.uts.edu.au/bitstream/10453/124122/1/01front.pdf. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Hven, Steffen. “Memento and the Embodied Fabula: Narrative Comprehension Revisited.” intapi.sciendo.com, DE Gruyter, 2015, https://intapi.sciendo.com/pdf/10.1515/ausfm-2015-0017. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Lapointe, Sierra. ““Meet Me in Montauk”: Michel Gondry's Incorporation of Avant-Garde Surrealist Practices in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004).” Offscreen, February 2022, https://offscreen.com/view/ameet-me-in-montauka-michel-gondryas-incorporation-of-avant-garde-surrealist-practices-in-eternal-sunshine-of-the-spotless-mind-2004. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Redfern, Nick. “(PDF) Film style and narration in Rashomon.” ResearchGate, 2014, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nick-Redfern-3/publication/261703042_Film_style_and_narration_in_Rashomon/links/00b7d53557f82691d1000000/Film-style-and-narration-in-Rashomon.pdf?_sg%5B0%5D=started_experiment_milestone&origin=journalDetail.  Accessed 25 March 2024.

Suganya, V., and B. Padmanabhan. “The Interpolation Of Memory And Nonlinear Narrative Structure In Sara Baume's A Line Made By Walking.” jetir.org, Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research, 2019, https://www.jetir.org/papers/JETIR1905C79.pdf. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Wang, Qiong. “A Brief Analysis on the Narrative Art of Pulp Fiction.”  paradigmpress.org, 2023, https://www.paradigmpress.org/as/article/view/447/390.  Accessed 25 March 2024.


Bibliography 

Primary Resources  


Gondry, Michel, director. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Anonymous Content, 2004.

Kurosawa, Akira, director. Rashomon. Daiei Film, 1950.

Nolan, Christopher, director. Memento. Summit Entertainment, 2000.

Tarantino, Quentin, director. Pulp Fiction. A Band Apart, 1994.


Secondary Resources 


Aprahamian, Steve. “File:Memento Timeline Plot vs Story.jpg.” Wikimedia Commons, 2 October 2009, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Memento_Timeline_Plot_vs_Story.jpg. Accessed 21 March 2024.

Bolewski, Christin. “Nonlinear narratives: crossing borders between contemporary film, art and digital media practice.” Loughborough University Research Repository, 2 October 2015, https://repository.lboro.ac.uk/articles/journal_contribution/Nonlinear_narratives_crossing_borders_between_contemporary_film_art_and_digital_media_practice/9335429 . Accessed 24 February 2024.

Booker, M. Keith. “Pulp Fiction (1994, directed by Quentin Tarantino), Comments on Culture.” bookerhorror.com, 2021, https://bookerhorror.com/pulp-fiction-1994-directed-by-quentin-tarantino/. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Bordwell, David. Poetics of Cinema. Taylor & Francis, 2012

“CINEMA Definition & Usage Examples.” Dictionary.com, https://www.dictionary.com/browse/cinemas.  Accessed 8 February 2024.

Brown, Larry A. How Films Tell Stories: The Narratology of Cinema. Creative Arts Press, 2016.

Buckland, Warren, editor. Puzzle Films: Complex Storytelling in Contemporary Cinema. Wiley, 2009.

Davis, Blair, et al., editors. Rashomon Effects: Kurosawa, Rashomon and Their Legacies. Taylor & Francis, 2015.

Eckhard, Petra, et al., editors. Landscapes of Postmodernity: Concepts and Paradigms of Critical Theory. Lit, 2010.

Eenoo, Cedric van. “Storytelling: Time, Space, Intervals.” opus.lib.uts.edu.au, OPUS Open Publications of UTS Scholars, 2018, https://opus.lib.uts.edu.au/bitstream/10453/124122/1/01front.pdf. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Erll, Astrid, and Ann Rigney, editors. Mediation, Remediation, and the Dynamics of Cultural Memory. Walter de Gruyter, 2009.

Heckmann, Chris. “History of Film Timeline — All Eras of Film History Explained.” StudioBinder, 1 January 2023, https://www.studiobinder.com/blog/the-history-of-film-timeline/.  Accessed 8 February 2024.

Howley, Kevin. “Breaking, Making, and Killing Time in Pulp Fiction.” University of Nottingham, 2004, https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/scope/documents/2004/may-2004/howley.pdf . Accessed 25 February 2024.

Hven, Steffen. “Memento and the Embodied Fabula: Narrative Comprehension Revisited.” Sciendo, Acta Universitatis Sapientiae, Film and Media Studies, 6 April 2016, https://sciendo.com/article/10.1515/ausfm-2015-0017 . Accessed 25 February 2024.

Johnson, Gigy. “Deriving meaning from chaos:Narrative analysis of Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind.” mbanimit.ac.in/, Naipunnya A Collection of Multidisciplinary Research Papers, 16 June 2020, http://mbanimit.ac.in/naac1/Uploads/20200616124421_combinepdf.pdf . Accessed 25 February 2024.

Klein, Andy. “Everything you wanted to know about "Memento."” Salon.com, 28 June 2001, https://www.salon.com/2001/06/28/memento_analysis/. Accessed 21 March 2024.

Lapointe, Sierra. ““Meet Me in Montauk”: Michel Gondry's Incorporation of Avant-Garde Surrealist Practices in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004).” Offscreen, February 2022, https://offscreen.com/view/ameet-me-in-montauka-michel-gondryas-incorporation-of-avant-garde-surrealist-practices-in-eternal-sunshine-of-the-spotless-mind-2004. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Little, William G. “Surviving "Memento."” jstor.org, Narrative, 2005, https://www.jstor.org/stable/20107363. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Livingston, Paisley, and Carl R. Plantinga, editors. The Routledge Companion to Philosophy and Film. Routledge, 2011.

Nowell-Smith, Geoffrey, editor. The Oxford History of World Cinema. Oxford University Press, 1996.

Nungesser, Verena-Susanna. “I Forgot to Remember (to Forget): Personal Memories in Memento (2000) and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004).” Wikipedia, degruyterbrill.com, 2009, https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110217384.1.31/pdf?licenseType=restricted. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Paiella, Giorgina Samira. “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Memory Erasure, and the Problem of Personal Identity.” PhilArchive, 30 March 2020, https://philarchive.org/archive/PAIESO. Accessed 24 March 2024.

Pearce, Celia. “The Ins & Outs of Non-Linear Storytelling.” dl.acm.org, Association for Computing Machinery New York, NY, United States, 6 May 2021, https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/178951.178956 . Accessed 24 February 2024.

Pratt, Sean. “Rashomon.” SBIFF, 3 November 2020, https://sbiff.org/election/. Accessed 25 March 2024.

Pu, Marina HS. “The Discussion Between Puzzle Film and Non- Linear Narrative Film.” Diamond Scientific Publishing, https://www.dpublication.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/22-2470.pdf . Accessed 24 February 2024.

Redfern, Nick. “(PDF) Film style and narration in Rashomon.” ResearchGate, 2014, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nick-Redfern-3/publication/261703042_Film_style_and_narration_in_Rashomon/links/00b7d53557f82691d1000000/Film-style-and-narration-in-Rashomon.pdf?_sg%5B0%5D=started_experiment_milestone&origin=journalDetail.  Accessed 25 March 2024.

Rombes, Nicholas, editor. New Punk Cinema. Edinburgh University Press, 2019.

Said, Nur Aainaa Amira Mohd, et al. “Joel’s Self-Redemption in the Unnatural Narrative Structure of Charlie Kaufman’s Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004).” Pertanika, 26 March 2021, http://119.40.116.186/resources/files/Pertanika%20PAPERS/JSSH%20Vol.%2029%20(1)%20Mar.%202021/26%20JSSH-7053-2020.pdf . Accessed 25 February 2024.

Seemann, Joshua. “Benefits Of Nonlinear Storytelling In Film And Television.” ScholarWorks, 2017, https://scholarworks.calstate.edu/downloads/0p096885m . Accessed 24 February 2024.

Sharma, Rasagy, And Venkatesh Rajamanickam. “Using Interactive Data Visualization to Explore Non-Linear Movie Narratives.” Parsons Institute for Information Mapping, 1 January 2015, http://piim.newschool.edu/journal/issues/2015/01/pdfs/ParsonsJournalForInformationMapping_Rasagy_Sharma.pdf . Accessed 24 February 2024.

Sikov, Ed. Film Studies: An Introduction. Columbia University Press, 2010.

Sudhakaran, Sareesh. “Why is Rashomon a Great Film?” Wolfcrow, 21 June 2021, https://wolfcrow.com/why-is-rashomon-a-great-film/.  Accessed 25 March 2024.

Suganya, V., and B. Padmanabhan. “The Interpolation Of Memory And Nonlinear Narrative Structure In Sara Baume's A Line Made By Walking.” jetir.org, Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research, 2019, https://www.jetir.org/papers/JETIR1905C79.pdf. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Thompson, Kristin. Storytelling in Film and Television. Harvard University Press, 1999. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1dp0tvx.  Accessed 7 Feb. 2024.

Tseng, Chiaoi, and John A. Bateman. “Multimodal narrative construction in Christopher Nolan’s Memento a description of analytic method.” journals.sagepub.com, SAGE Publications, 6 January 2023, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1470357211424691. Accessed 22 March 2024.

Wang, Qiong. “A Brief Analysis on the Narrative Art of Pulp Fiction.” Paradigm Press, 6 February 2023, https://www.paradigmpress.org/as/article/download/447/390 . Accessed 25 February 2024.


Reimagining Comparative Literature for the Digital Age: Toward Comparative Media Studies, Data Analytics, and Collaborative Knowledge Production

This blog is written as assignment of the Semester 4 of the M.A. in English for the paper Comparative Literature & Translation Studieson the topic, Reimagining Comparative Literature for the Digital Age: Toward Comparative Media Studies, Data Analytics, and Collaborative Knowledge Production



 Name: Ghanshyam Katariya

Paper 208: Comparative Literature & Translation Studies

Subject Code:  22415

Topic Name: Reimagining Comparative Literature for the Digital Age: Toward Comparative Media Studies, Data Analytics, and Collaborative Knowledge Production

Batch: M.A. Sem-4(2022-24)

Roll No: 7

Enrolment No: 4069206420220017

Email Address: gkatariya67@gmail.com

Submitted to: Smt. S. B. Gardi, Department of English, MKBU

Title: ‘Reimagining Comparative Literature for the Digital Age: Toward Comparative Media Studies, Data Analytics, and Collaborative Knowledge Production’



Introduction


The development of the printing press and the "discovery" of the New World were watershed moments in human history, unleashing profound transformations in society and culture. The printing press revolutionized communication, literacy, and the state of knowledge, providing the conditions for the Reformation, the Enlightenment, the age of Humanism, and the rise of mass media. Innovations in print technology became the very instrument for producing, sharing, and transforming humanistic and scientific knowledge.

The opening up of the New World exposed the profound limitations of conventional knowledge and epistemologies, reconfiguring the entire surface of the earth. It enabled the ascendancy of rationality (and its deep link to barbarism), gave rise to new economies, provided the seedbed for colonialism, and was the prerequisite for the modern nation-state.

Both the impact of print and the "discovery" of the New World were predicated on networking technologies, which not only enabled the dissemination of knowledge into new cultural and social spheres but also brought together people, nations, cultures, and languages that were previously separated. These transformative technologies facilitated a potential democratization of information and exchange on the one hand, and the ability to exercise exclusionary control and violence on the other.

Today, we are in the midst of another watershed moment in human history, comparable to the invention of the printing press or the discovery of the New World. The changes brought about by new communication technologies – including web-based media forms, locative technologies, digital archives, cloud computing, social networking, and mixed realities – are so sweeping in scope and significance that they may appropriately be compared to these previous transformative events.

These contemporary changes are happening on a very rapid timescale, taking place over months and years rather than decades and centuries. As such, the intellectual tools, methodologies, and disciplinary practices have just started to emerge for responding to, engaging with, and interpreting the massive social, cultural, economic, and educational transformations happening all around us. It is crucial for humanists to assert and insert themselves into these cultural shifts, as they have the critical role of understanding, critiquing, comparing, historicizing, and evaluating the explosion of digital publications, platforms, and the cultural, social, and economic shifts they enable (or prevent).


Defining Digital Humanities

Digital Humanities is an umbrella term for a wide array of interdisciplinary practices for creating, applying, interpreting, interrogating, and hacking both new and old information technologies. These practices are not limited to conventional Humanities departments and disciplines but affect every humanistic field at the university and transform the ways in which humanistic knowledge reaches and engages with communities outside the university.

Digital Humanities projects are almost always collaborative, engaging humanists, technologists, librarians, social scientists, artists, architects, information scientists, and computer scientists in conceptualizing problems, designing interfaces, analyzing data, sharing knowledge, and engaging with a significantly broader public than traditional academic research in the Humanities.

Digital Humanities is an outgrowth and expansion of the traditional scope of the Humanities, not a replacement or rejection of humanistic inquiry. The role of the humanist is critical at this historic moment, as our cultural legacy as a species migrates to digital formats and our relation to knowledge, cultural material, technology, and society at large is radically re-conceptualized.

Digital Humanities represents a field that goes beyond traditional disciplinary boundaries, facilitating collaborative projects that apply new technologies to interpret and engage with cultural materials and knowledge production. Rather than being confined to specific departments, Digital Humanities expands the scope of the humanities by involving various disciplines and engaging with diverse communities beyond academia.


Three Futures for Comparative Literature in the Digital Age


The digital revolution is fundamentally reshaping the field of comparative literature, requiring scholars to reimagine their research methods, objects of study, and modes of knowledge production. Presner outlines three interrelated futures that envision how the discipline can evolve and thrive by deeply engaging the materialities, methodologies, and platforms of digital media and culture. Rather than being constrained to printed texts, these futures map out ways for comparative literature to analyze the specificity of different media forms, apply computational techniques to massive cultural datasets, and embrace collaborative authorship models facilitated by digital technologies. In doing so, they catalyze a radical rethinking of how humanities knowledge gets created, evaluated, and disseminated in the 21st century.


Comparative Media Studies 

Comparative Media Studies foregrounds the formal material qualities of the surface structures upon which inscriptions are made, the technical processes of reproduction and circulation, the institutional mechanisms of dissemination and authorization, the reading and navigation practices enabled by the media form, and the broad cultural and social implications for literacy and knowledge production. As Presner states, "It investigates all media as information and knowledge systems that are bound up with histories of power, institutions, and governing and regulatory bodies which legitimate and authorize certain utterances, while screening out and dismissing others."

Comparative Media Studies implies that scholarly "work" is not uni-medial and might not even be textual. It draws attention to the design and interrelationship of every unit of the argument, interrogating "the spatio-temporal elements of the layout, its look and feel, its visual organization, the curatorial pathways, the user or reader's interface, the indexing and access system, and the processes of enabling legibility through selection and assembly."


Comparative Data Studies 

Comparative Data Studies allows scholars to use computational tools of "cultural analytics" to analyze large-scale cultural datasets, whether historical data that has been digitized or contemporary real-time data flows. As Presner states, "Because meaning, argumentation, and interpretative work are not limited to the 'insides' of texts or necessarily even require 'close' readings, Comparative Data Studies allows us to use the computational tools of cultural analytics to enhance literary scholarship precisely by creating models, visualizations, maps, and semantic webs of data that are simply too large to read or comprehend using unaided human faculties."

This approach combines "close" hermeneutical readings with "distant" data mappings, appreciating the synergies between localized deep analysis and macrocosmic views. Moreover, it radically expands the canon of objects under consideration to include not just traditional print artifacts but also "born digital" blogs, videos, maps, and hypermedia that combine different media types.


Comparative Authorship and Platform Studies

Comparative Authorship and Platform Studies examines how the barriers for creating, sharing, and evaluating content have been lowered by digital technologies, enabling collaborative authorship, peer-to-peer sharing, and crowd-sourced evaluation to flourish. As Presner notes, "We no longer just 'browse' and passively consume predigested content but are actively engaged in the production, annotation, and evaluation of digital media and software thanks to the open-source movement."

This approach is concerned with the design of scholarly platforms, interfaces, database schemas, navigation features, and how choices about these elements stage arguments in the digital realm. Scholarly outputs are increasingly multimodal, requiring close collaboration between scholars, designers, and technologists.

Presner highlights Wikipedia as "a truly innovative, global, multilingual, collaborative knowledge-generating community and platform for authoring, editing, distributing, and versioning knowledge." Its open editing model represents a revolutionary approach to collective knowledge production that underscores "process, collaboration, access, interactivity, and creativity."


Conclusion


The digital age is rapidly transforming the landscape of comparative literature and the humanities more broadly. As Presner compellingly argues, the intellectual tools and modes of knowledge production that served the era of print media are no longer sufficient for engaging the profound technological, social and cultural shifts ushered in by digital media and technologies. The three futures he outlines - comparative media studies, comparative data studies, and comparative authorship and platform studies - collectively chart an ambitious reorientation of the discipline.

By foregrounding the analysis of media materialities, applying computational methods to massive cultural datasets, and embracing collaborative digital authorship models, these approaches catalyse a radical rethinking of comparative literature's theories, methods, and institutional structures. They propel the field into productive dialogues with technology, data science, design and participatory culture. No longer constrained to the printed text, these futures envision new ways of creating, analysing and disseminating humanities knowledge attuned to the realities and scales of the digital present and future.

Realising this vital remaking of comparative literature will face significant challenges. Overcoming the field's entrenched print-based paradigms, building interdisciplinary partnerships, securing resources for digital humanities work, and shaping emerging scholarly cyberinfrastructures in democratising ways will require sustained advocacy and critical vigilance. There are also important questions around negotiating proprietary platforms, restrictive intellectual property regimes, and ensuring more voices get empowered rather than traditional exclusions replicated.

Presner makes a powerful case that deeply engaging digital technologies and culture is not only essential for comparative literature's continued relevance, but also for humanists to help society thoughtfully navigate this new era. As our cultural legacy increasingly takes digital form, it is crucial that humanists assert their vital expertise in interpretation, cultural analysis and theoretical reflection to understand, critique and shape these technologies. Presner's articulation of potential digital futures for the discipline provides a vital roadmap for reinventing comparative literature as a publicly-engaged, boundary-crossing field distinctly adapted to flourish in the 21st century digital world.






Work Cited

Presner, Todd. "Comparative Literature in the Age of Digital Humanities: On Possible Futures for a Discipline." A Companion to Comparative Literature (2011): 193-207.


Understanding Plagiarism and Its Consequences

This blog is written as assignment of the Semester 4 of the M.A. in English for the paper Research Methodology  on the topic, Understanding Plagiarism and Its Consequences


 Name: Ghanshyam Katariya

Paper 209: Research Methodology 

Subject Code:  22416

Topic Name: Understanding Plagiarism and Its Consequences

Batch: M.A. Sem-4(2022-24)

Roll No: 7

Enrolment No: 4069206420220017

Email Address: gkatariya67@gmail.com

Submitted to: Smt. S. B. Gardi, Department of English, MKBU


Title : Understanding Plagiarism and Its Consequences


Introduction:

Plagiarism is a serious issue that has far-reaching consequences in academic and professional settings. According to the Oxford definition, plagiarism is "Presenting work or ideas from another source as your own, with or without consent of the original author, by incorporating it into your work without full acknowledgement. All published and unpublished material, whether in manuscript, printed or electronic form, is covered under this definition, as is the use of material generated wholly or in part through use of artificial intelligence." (“Plagiarism”)

Plagiarism undermines the principles of academic integrity, intellectual property rights, and ethical conduct. It not only violates the norms of scholarly and professional communities but also erodes the credibility and value of one's work. Consequently, educational institutions and professional organisations have strict policies and procedures in place to detect and address instances of plagiarism.

“Plagiarism is sometimes a moral and ethical offense ratherthan a legal one since some instances of plagiarism fall outside the scope of copyright infringement, a legal offense.” (MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers)

 Consequences of Plagiarism

The charge of plagiarism is a serious one for all writers. Plagiarists are often seen as incompetent-incapable of developing and expressing their own thoughts-or, worse, dishonest, willing to deceive others for personal gain. (MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers)

Plagiarism, the act of presenting someone else's work as one's own, carries severe consequences that can have far-reaching implications. Academically, plagiarism can lead to disciplinary actions such as failing a course, suspension, or even expulsion from educational institutions. Additionally, it can tarnish an individual's reputation, making it difficult to secure future academic or professional opportunities.

Beyond academia, plagiarism can have legal ramifications, particularly in the realm of intellectual property rights. Individuals or organizations found guilty of plagiarism may face legal actions, including hefty fines or even criminal charges in extreme cases. This can result in significant financial losses and irreparable damage to one's credibility and standing.

The consequences of plagiarism extend beyond the individual, as it can undermine the integrity and credibility of entire institutions. For instance, cases of plagiarism in scientific research can discredit the findings and cast doubt on the institution's commitment to ethical practices, ultimately eroding public trust.

Real-world examples underscore the severity of plagiarism's repercussions. In 2011, a German defense minister resigned after being accused of plagiarizing substantial portions of her doctoral dissertation. Similarly, in 2012, a renowned Harvard scholar returned her academic credentials amidst allegations of plagiarism in her bestselling book.

Plagiarism not only violates ethical principles but also carries severe consequences that can have lasting impacts on individuals, institutions, and the broader society. It is crucial to uphold academic integrity and respect intellectual property rights to maintain credibility and trust in the academic and professional realms.

Forms of Plagiarism

Plagiarism takes various insidious forms like Verbatim plagiarism, mosaic plagiarism, paraphrasing, self-plagiarism, cyber plagiarism, image plagiarism (Haq), each involving the unethical use of another's intellectual property without proper attribution. One prevalent form is directly copying someone else's words or passages verbatim without enclosing them in quotation marks or citing the original source. Even paraphrasing another's wording by making minor changes while retaining the essence constitutes plagiarism if not credited appropriately.

Another form is the unauthorized use of unique phrases, terms or expressions coined by a particular author or source. For example, using Michael Agar's invented term "languaculture" to describe the intersection of language and culture without acknowledging him plagiarizes his original thinking.

Additionally, plagiarism can manifest through appropriating the ideas, theories, arguments or lines of reasoning presented by others and repackaging them as one's own original thoughts. Alvin Toffler's conceptualization of historical "waves" of change provides a clear example - paraphrasing his perspective on agricultural, industrial and imminent revolutionary eras without citation constitutes plagiarism.

Each of these forms damages academic and intellectual integrity. Presenting others' words, expressions or conceptual frameworks as one's own original work deceives the audience and violates ethical norms. It also infringes on the intellectual property rights of the original innovators whose labor produced the plagiarized material. Flagrant disregard for proper attribution undercuts the credibility of academic institutions.

Detection and Prevention Strategies:

Detecting and preventing plagiarism is crucial for maintaining academic integrity and promoting original, ethical work. Proper citation practices are essential in avoiding plagiarism. Writers should familiarize themselves with citation styles like MLA or APA and meticulously cite all sources used, whether directly quoted, paraphrased, or serving as inspiration for ideas. Citation guidelines outline how to format in-text citations and reference lists, ensuring transparency.

Effective paraphrasing is also key. Rather than simply rearranging sentences, true paraphrasing involves fully understanding the original text and rewriting it in one's own words and structure while preserving the meaning. Checking paraphrased text against the original can help ensure no verbatim phrases slip through accidentally.

Plagiarism detection software like Turnitin can be invaluable tools. These programs cross-reference submitted work against databases of published material, scholarly sources, and previous student submissions to identify potential plagiarism. However, they should be used judiciously alongside human review, as they cannot catch skillful paraphrasing or detect uncited reuse of one's own prior work. “It is generally difficult to detect plagiarism, but information technology has made available few websites which can detect/catch plagiarism. Few of them are www.ithentical. com, www.turnitin.com, www.plagiarism.org, etc. “(Haq)

Other issues related to plagiarism and academic integrity

Reusing a research paper that was previously submitted for credit in another course is considered deceitful. Not only does it constitute academic dishonesty, but it robs the student of the opportunity to further develop their knowledge and skills. If a student wishes to build upon or rework aspects of prior work, they must seek explicit permission from the instructor and follow any guidelines provided.

Collaborative work on group projects or joint research necessitates properly attributing credit to all contributors. In many courses and professional settings, such collaboration is actively encouraged. However, to avoid plagiarism, distinct roles must be delineated if contributions were unequal, or all participants must be equally acknowledged if efforts were merged. Students should consult their instructor if unclear on how to properly credit collaboration.

Research involving human subjects, like clinical trials or interviews for psychological studies, is another area governed by institutional policies. These often require researchers to obtain informed consent from participants. Though rare for typical student papers, those conducting such research should inquire about their institution's specific regulations.

Copyright infringement poses legal ramifications beyond plagiarism. While limited quotation with citation is generally permissible, reproducing entire copyrighted works or large portions without the holder's authorization constitutes violation of copyright law, regardless of acknowledgment of the source. This applies to all published media. Consulting style guides like the MLA Manual is advisable for further detail on copyright and publishing laws.

Importance of Academic Integrity

Academic integrity is the foundational pillar upon which the credibility and validity of scholarly work rests. It fosters an environment of honesty, trust, and mutual respect within academic communities, nurturing a culture where knowledge can thrive and progress unimpeded.

Maintaining academic integrity is crucial for the advancement of knowledge and scholarship. By upholding ethical standards and ensuring that ideas, theories, and findings are accurately attributed to their original sources, academic integrity preserves the intellectual property rights of researchers and thinkers. This not only safeguards their contributions but also enables future scholars to build upon existing knowledge, facilitating the continuous expansion of human understanding.

Academic integrity promotes intellectual humility and a spirit of collaboration. When researchers transparently acknowledge the work of others upon which their own findings are based, it fosters a sense of interconnectedness within the scholarly community. This interconnectedness encourages the free exchange of ideas, constructive critique, and fruitful discourse, all of which are essential for the rigorous testing and refinement of academic theories and concepts.

A disregard for academic integrity can undermine the very foundations of knowledge and erode public trust in academic institutions. Plagiarism, data falsification, and other breaches of integrity compromise the reliability and credibility of research, potentially leading to wasted resources, misguided policies, and stunted progress.

It is imperative that students, researchers, and academics at all levels embrace and uphold the principles of academic integrity. By doing so, they not only safeguard their own reputations but also contribute to the broader pursuit of knowledge. Academic integrity should permeate every aspect of scholarly work, from conducting research and analyzing data to writing papers and presenting findings.

Academic integrity is a shared responsibility that requires unwavering commitment from all members of the academic community. By fostering an environment of honesty, transparency, and ethical conduct, we can ensure that the pursuit of knowledge remains a noble and trustworthy endeavor, one that continues to enlighten and enrich our understanding of the world.

Conclusion 

plagiarism represents a significant threat to academic integrity, intellectual property rights, and the credibility of scholarly work. Its consequences can be severe, ranging from academic penalties and reputational damage to potential legal ramifications. Various insidious forms of plagiarism, including verbatim copying, improper paraphrasing, and appropriating others' ideas without attribution, all violate ethical norms and undermine the advancement of knowledge.

Combating plagiarism requires a multi-pronged approach involving proper citation practices, effective paraphrasing techniques, and the judicious use of plagiarism detection software alongside human review. However, the ultimate responsibility lies with individuals at all levels of the academic community to uphold the principles of academic integrity through unwavering commitment to honesty, transparency, and ethical conduct.


Works Cited

Awasthi, Shipra, and Jawaharlal Nehru. “Plagiarism and Academic Misconduct A Systematic Review | DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology.” Defence Science Journal, 11 March 2019, https://publications.drdo.gov.in/ojs/index.php/djlit/article/view/13622. Accessed 25 April 2024.

Haq, Rehan Ul. “What is plagiarism and how to avoid it?” NCBI, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5122250/. Accessed 25 April 2024.

MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers. Modern Language Association of America, 2009.

“Plagiarism.” University of Oxford, https://www.ox.ac.uk/students/academic/guidance/skills/plagiarism. Accessed 25 April 2024.






Assignment- 5 Research Project Writing: Dissertation Writing - Research Writing

Name: Ghanshyam Katariya Paper 210A: Research Project Writing: Dissertation Writing - Research Writing  Subject Code: 22417 Topic Name:  Nav...